• Home
  • Trends
  • Company News
  • Product News
  • Fashion
  • Podcast
  • Events
  • About
  • Contact
  • May 9, 2025

Wearable Tech Insider

The Inside Word on Wearables and Wearable Technology

You are here: Home / General News / JAMA Says Fitbit Makes The Most Accurate Fitness Tracker, But It’s Not The One You Think

JAMA Says Fitbit Makes The Most Accurate Fitness Tracker, But It’s Not The One You Think

February 11, 2015 By Dan Rosenbaum

fitbit oneThe apparent inaccuracy of wearable fitness trackers has long bugged us, but we had been unable to put real scientific numbers to it. Fortunately, there are real researchers in the world, and they’ve established scientifically that most of the step-counting data you get from trackers is pretty bad.

A letter in the Journal of the American Medical Association — as mainstream a medical research publication as there is — compared the Nike Fuelband; Fitbit Zip, One, and Flex; the Jawbone UP 24; three iPhone apps, and a Galaxy 5 app. Participants each walked 500 and 1500 steps on a treadmill twice. A total of 560 observations were taken; each device or app got 27 or 28 data points.

(A “letter” to JAMA, by the way, is peer-reviewed but not as long, in-depth, or technical as a full journal article. It’s still pretty prestigious.)

The full letter is behind a paywall, but the first page has plenty of good data and conclusions. As a class, researchers found, the phones did best, averaging very close to the correct number of steps and varying by about 10 percent up or down. The Nike Fuelband did terribly, consistently undercounting by an average of about 20 percent and with a variability that renders its data meaningless. The Fitbit Flex undercounted slightly, with a range pretty close to what the phones reported.

But the real champs were the Fitbit One and Zip — devices that clip to your clothing, not hang on your wrist. In every test, they counted correctly and with only a tiny variance.

The implication here is interesting. Stuff you wear on your wrist would appear to be prone to the larges error, possibly because swinging your arm is not the same thing as a taking a step. Stuff you carry in your pocket is next best, maybe for the same reason: it doesn’t move around as much. Stuff that’s more or less stationary — clipped to clothing — is the most accurate of all. It’s not clear what happens when you combine two locations, like wrist and pocket, the way Samsung does and Apple will soon have.

There are a lot of reasons to wear devices on your wrist, fashion and design not least among them. If you want accuracy in a fitness device, though, the JAMA data implies that the wrist might be the wrong place for it — a finding that may have serious implications for the smartband business. For sure, though: I’m taking off my Fuelband, because it’s apparently spouting nonsense.

 

Last updated by Dan Rosenbaum on February 1, 2017.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Email

Related

Filed Under: General News, Medical, Trends Tagged With: fitbit, fitness, fuelband, galaxy, iphone, JAMA, nike, research

← The Search for a New Battery Engadget Review of Healbe GoBe: Not a Fraud, but Not a Winner Either →

Recent Posts

New Use Case for Apple Watch: Red Sox Stealing Signs

Fossil Debuts Two Android Wear Smartwatches

Garmin Shows Three New Fitness Bands at IFA

Fitbit Ionic: Minimal Acceptable Product?

Intel (Finally) Ditches Wearables for AR

Don’t Believe Everything You Read: Wearables Are Far From Dead

Eyes F.lashing Before Your Life

Smarty Pants: Nadi X Yoga Leggings

Rings: How Smart Can They Be?

Upskill Closes Series B Financing, But Won’t Say How Much

Stories from Health Tech Insider

  • Remote Monitoring Drives New Personalized Treatment for Chronic Breathing Problems
  • Wearable Technology Listens for Knee Damage [video]
  • New Bandages Promise Faster Healing for Stubborn Wounds
  • CVS Acquires Telehealth Service to Bring Healthcare to the Home
  • Masimo’s New Smartwatch Addresses Privacy Concerns
  • Continuous Real-Time Diagnostics On the Go [video]

Topics

2013 android android wear apple apple watch apx labs basis battery CES ces2016 CES2017 epson finance fitbit fitness fossil fuelband garmin gear glass google healthkit intel iWatch jawbone LG market research microsoft misfit MWC15 nfc nike omate omsignal pebble recon samsung smartwatch sony sports tizen vuzix withings wristware wristwear

Copyright 2016 Center Ring Media | Site by JRMC